Thanks! Please confirm your subscription from your email inbox
Error! Please enter a valid zip code
Price is the easiest thing to compare between insurers, and the least reliable one to compare alone. A cheap quote from a company that's slow to pay claims, or that raises your rate sharply at renewal, can end up costing more than a slightly pricier policy from a company that doesn't.
A friend's recommendation or a single online review reflects one person's experience, shaped by factors that may not apply to you — their state, their claim history, even which local agent they dealt with. It's a data point, not the whole picture.
Two kinds of independent ratings are worth checking before you buy:
These two ratings measure different things, so it's worth checking both — a financially strong company can still have poor service, and a well-liked company can still be in financial trouble.
Before you request quotes, write down exactly what you currently have: your coverage types, your deductibles, and your mileage estimate. These details are easy to overlook but can shift a quote by hundreds of dollars, and comparing two quotes with different coverage levels tells you nothing useful. Use a quote comparison tool that lets you see multiple offers side by side, filter out companies with weak financial ratings even if their price looks good, and then narrow down to a shortlist before deciding.
Use our quote box below to compare current rates from several carriers side by side.
Most of the effort in getting five quotes is typing the same facts five times. Collect them once and each extra quote takes a couple of minutes: year, make, model and VIN for each vehicle; licence details and dates of birth for every driver in the household; the garaging address; annual mileage and how the car is used; violations and at-fault accidents from roughly the last five years; and your current policy's declarations page, which lists the limits and deductibles every new quote should be measured against.
You can buy the same cover three ways, and each suits a different situation. Buying direct from an insurer, online or by phone, is quickest and makes like-for-like comparison easy. A captive agent represents one company and knows its products and discounts in depth. An independent agent or broker places business with several carriers and earns their keep on complicated cases — an SR-22 filing, a salvage title, a recent DUI, a classic car needing agreed-value cover, or a household that has been turned down elsewhere.
A broker is not automatically more expensive, but they are not automatically cheaper either, and they will not represent every insurer in the market. If your situation is straightforward, quoting directly with several carriers and then calling the shortlist usually gets you there.
Two ratings matter, and they measure different things: financial strength, which is whether the insurer can pay a large claim, and customer satisfaction or complaint records, which is whether it will do so without a fight. Your state's department of insurance publishes complaint data by company, and it is the most useful single source because it reflects your own state's experience rather than a national average.
Also worth checking before you sign: how claims are reported and whether there is 24-hour service; whether the insurer uses approved repair networks or lets you choose a shop; how rental cover during repairs works; and whether the quote assumes paperless billing or automatic payment to reach the price shown.
A quote is only cheaper if it is the same policy. Hold the liability limits, deductibles, optional cover and the list of drivers steady across every quote. A price that is several hundred dollars lower often carries a higher deductible, thinner liability limits, or a driver quietly left off — none of which is a saving, and the last of which can cost you a claim.
AutoInsuranceQuery editorial team. Last reviewed: September 29, 2026.
